Search
16:45:36
Xof
yeah, but. If any applicable &key method also had &rest, :c would be acceptable
16:45:49
Xof
the generic function lambda list has &rest.
16:46:06
Xof
This might be a question of inferred intent vs letter of the law
16:46:18
Xof
(and maybe we should signal an error, just because someone else does)
16:48:31
jackdaniel
clisp does; abcl, ccl, ecl and sbcl doesn't (I don't have other implementations locally)
16:55:34
makomo
Xof: would it though? why would the existence of &rest along with &key disable the checking of the validity of the keyword arguments?
16:55:44
makomo
CLISP signals an error in that case too
16:56:05
makomo
^ the above is within methods of course, the generic function still only has &rest